{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average American home consistently fetched prices higher than the previous year, but that trend has come to a halt. Data from October reveals that the median sale price of homes has dipped slightly below last year's figures, marking the first annual decrease since the spring of 2023. Concurrently, the amount of homes available for sale has reached its highest point since early 2020, while pending sales have plummeted to their lowest level in more than ten years, excluding the onset of the pandemic. Notably, one in five listings has experienced a price reduction.

Nonetheless, borrowing costs have surged once again. The average mortgage rate for a 30-year fixed loan has risen back to the mid-7% range following a short period of relief. As a result, while buyers find themselves in a stronger negotiating position, managing monthly payments remains a concern for numerous households.

This unique situation presents an opportunity. Sellers are receiving fewer offers and their properties are remaining on the market for extended periods. This shift indicates that list prices and terms are becoming more negotiable than before. If you are on the hunt for a home this winter, consider what aspects may be up for negotiation, and how to evaluate them with the support of your agent and lender.

Understanding the significance of a minor price decline

A national decrease of less than half a percent is not catastrophic and doesn't suggest a widespread decline in prices. Certain high-demand coastal markets with minimal inventory continue to experience price gains, while a number of large cities in the South and West have witnessed price drops of several percentage points compared to the previous year. The conditions in your local market play a crucial role, often overshadowing national trends.

The overall market data indicates a shift in dynamic. As homes are taking longer to sell and more listings compete for a dwindling pool of buyers, sellers become increasingly open to negotiation. This can reflect in both pricing and other sale terms.

More than just the price

While many buyers may focus solely on the sale price, in a landscape of rising interest rates, the total monthly payment and required cash at closing can be of equal or greater importance. Reductions in the sale price might only marginally affect the loan amount. On the contrary, using those savings strategically can yield greater benefits for your finances. Buyers in this market often consider:

  • A purchase price below the listed amount
  • A credit from the seller to help cover closing costs
  • Completion of necessary repairs prior to settlement, or a credit instead of repairs
  • Seller assistance to reduce your mortgage interest rate
  • A timeline for closing or moving that aligns with your plans
  • Inclusions like appliances or window treatments that remain in the home

Your real estate agent can provide insights into how local sellers are responding and assist in prioritizing which requests to make when presenting an offer. It's advisable to focus on the key factors that will significantly impact your situation rather than asking for everything.

Credits for closing costs may alleviate financial strain

Typically, closing costs amount to several percent of the loan value, which, when combined with your down payment, can pose a significant hurdle for first-time buyers. Seller credits can offset some of these costs directly, allowing you to bring less money at finalization.

However, there are limits to these arrangements. Different loan programs have caps on how much a seller can contribute, usually between 3% and 9%, depending on the type of loan and your down payment size. Additionally, the amount of seller credit cannot exceed your actual closing costs. It is wise to discuss with your lender early on what your specific loan allows so that your offers stay compliant.

Understanding rate buydowns

As mortgage rates have surpassed 7%, one valuable offering from sellers can be assistance with securing a lower interest rate. There are generally two main methods for this.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to secure a lower interest rate for the lifetime of the loan. Each point incurs a cost of 1% of the loan amount, and the resulting rate reduction can vary by lender and prevailing market conditions. If you intend to hold onto the loan for many years, a permanent buydown may yield significant savings.

A temporary buydown, on the other hand, reduces your payments initially for a year or two. A common scenario is to have the rate drop by two percentage points during the first year and one point in the second year, reverting to the full rate thereafter. For instance, on a $350,000 loan at approximately 7.34%, the first-year payment would adjust to about $1,952, while the second would be around $2,176, before returning to the full payment in the third year. Generally, covering this arrangement can cost just over $8,000, which a seller might prefer to offer instead of agreeing to a price cut of a similar amount.

However, a temporary buydown isn't a long-term solution. You must be sure you can manage the full payment once the temporary relief concludes, and lenders usually qualify borrowers based on the full interest rate. If interest rates drop in the future, refinancing might be a possibility, though there are no guarantees regarding timing or outcomes.

Don't forgo inspections to appear more competitive

In a red-hot market, many buyers opted to waive inspections or limit their requests to outbid competitors. In a more lenient market, this pressure diminishes, allowing you to retain these protections. Conducting a detailed inspection provides insights into various aspects of the home, such as the condition of the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical setups, and foundation integrity before making a commitment.

If any issues arise during the inspection, your agent can guide you on whether to request repairs, adjust the price, or seek a credit. Sometimes, credits can prove simpler than repairs managed by the seller, as they give you control over the work done and the individual performing it, but the right choice ultimately depends on the issue at hand and your loan's stipulations.

Prepare your financing beforehand

Having negotiating strength is futile if your financing isn't solid. When faced with two offers, sellers usually prefer buyers who appear most likely to close. Before seriously pursuing homes, secure full preapproval rather than just quick prequalification, determine your comfortable monthly payment instead of merely the highest loan amount, and obtain loan estimates from multiple lenders. Inquire about each lender's process for managing seller credits or rate buydowns to avoid surprises later on.

Key questions to discuss with your agent

  • How long are homes in this area typically listed before selling, and how frequently are prices cut?
  • Would a price reduction, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown be most beneficial for my budget?
  • How does this specific home's condition and history influence my requests?
  • What contingencies should I include to protect myself in my offer?

Final thoughts

Even though a cooler market can ease buying costs, especially with rising mortgage rates, it allows well-prepared buyers to negotiate deals that better align with their financial capabilities. With adequate financing, a clear understanding of your priorities, and the counsel of your agent and lender, you may find yourself securing more favorable terms compared to what was possible last year.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message